We tasted in order Otter Creek Oktoberfest, Stoudts Oktober Fest, and Victory Festbier. Unfortunately, we were disappointed. If we had to purchase one of these beers again, Robeer would choose the Otter Creek, though he found it bland. I would not choose the Victory. Stoudts was evervescent like a cider but not as complex. Victory tasted by crushed juniper berries and I only like gin with tonic on hot and humid day. Robeer thought this beer tasted metallic.